The program for the 2009 PIUG NE Meeting held on October 13, 2009, at the Hyatt Regency in New Brunswick, NJ is included below. Full conference details are at http://www.piug.org/Northeast/2009/ne09prog.php.
Conference presentations have been provided to PIUG members and conference attendees with permission of the presenters. They are available on the PIUG 2009 Northeast Conference Papers - October 2009 page in the PIUG wiki members-only section. Conference attendees who haven't joined PIUG should consider joining now since their memberships (and all renewals) will extend through 2010; see the PIUG membership page for details. Otherwise, if you attended the Northeast Conference and want access to these conference presentations, please contact the PIUG wikimaster by email.
Martin Goffman, Ph.D.
President and CEO, SequenceBase Corporation
Tel: +(732) 549-5433
mgoffman at sequencebase dot com, http://www.sequencebase.com
Richard W. Williams, Vertex Pharmaceuticals, Inc.
PIUG NE 2009 Meeting Co-Chairs
Vendor Exhibits Open - 7:30am - 8:15am
Morning Presentations - 8:15am - noon
Update on Patent Rules, Patent Reform, and Case Law
Rouget (Ric) Henschel - Foley & Lardner LLC
Have we returned to the days when the PTO's mantra was "We are the patent office, not the rejection office"? Perhaps. New leadership is in place at the PTO: David Kappos as Director and 35-year PTO veteran Bob Stoll as Commissioner for Patents. The Federal Circuit has ruled that the PTO rule changes are for the most part within the PTO's authority -- will the PTO proceed or decline to finalize the rule changes? Patent reform is stalled for now. The courts have been active: Bilski, KSR, Ariad v. Eli Lilly, Prometheus v. Mayo. It remains true that there is never a dull moment in patent law!
A Class on Classifications
Jim Brown - FIZ Karlsruhe
Patent classifications are powerful tools in performing comprehensive and efficient searches. Patent documents are classified by up to four different major classification systems - the international classification, European classification, US classification and Japanese classification systems. This talk will give an overview of each of those four systems; how to find the proper classifications in each system, how they are applied, updated, etc. Also included in the talk will be some examples showing the benefits of the different systems.
Semantic Search - Opening the Black Box
Mike Hudelson - LexisNexis
This paper will discuss the definition of semantic search, the types of solutions that have been historically labeled semantic, and the modern state of the art today. Emphasis will be on dynamic vs. static, "black box" vs. open and indexed vs. non-indexed systems. This latest version of semantic search will be discussed and contrasted with prior semantic solutions.
Chinese Utility Model Patenting - Trends Within a Lesser Known Prior Art Source
Bob Stembridge - Thomson Reuters
Filings for invention patents in China have been growing at an average of over 24% per annum since the turn of the new millennium. Last year, just shy of 290,000 invention patent applications were published by the Chinese Patent Office. However, this is not the complete story.
An alternative protection is available to inventors through Chinese Utility Model patents. These lesser known patents provide a more affordable route for protection of inventions and hence are very popular with Chinese domestic innovators. Annual filing growth rates are significant at over 16% per annum since 2000. Last year, just over 225,000 of these patents were published by the Chinese Patent Office. More importantly, very few of these patents are filed outside China and hence are available only in Chinese, yet they constitute publicly published information and therefore form an important part of the prior art.
This presentation will review sources of Chinese Utility Model information and will report original research conducted to highlight where the innovation disclosed in Chinese Utility model patents is originating, who is using this route to protect their innovation and in what technology areas this method of IP protection is most used.
Successfully Managing the Patent Lifecycle
David Dickens - CPA Global [did not attend]
Managing the patent lifecycle, from idea creation and development through invention submission and prosecution, all the way to portfolio management and litigation support, can be as complicated as it is essential to a healthy enterprise. Further complications or obstacles can arise from the involvement of a wide range of players (including corporate R&D centers, corporate legal departments, and IP researchers) that may be located in different geographic regions and time zones. Successful navigation of the challenges inherent in this lifecycle can increase collaboration and research quality, and significantly strengthen the decision making process, resulting in decreasing the time to market. We will review some recent technologies available to help streamline this process, focusing on collaboration and researcher tools, and advancing a discussion of what these tools can and cannot to do assist in these complex and al processes.
Patent Research in India: Challenges and Best Practices
Ashish Nawani - Evaluserve
India and China have emerged as big powerhouses in global economy with rapidly expanding markets and hubs for research and development. Accordingly, the need and importance of IP protection and enforcement in these countries have increased proportionately. The patenting landscapes in these countries are undergoing rapid changes due to surge in patent filing and reforms initiated by the government to improve IP infrastructure. India is specially important for pharma community as it has a strong presence in APIs (it holds the largest number of DMFs outside US) and is gradually moving towards innovative research. Also, it allows for both pre grant and post grant opposition.
Often, lack of thorough IP research has lead multinationals into difficult situations, as witnessed in recent litigation cases involving multinational companies in these emerging markets. Conducting thorough patent research is, hence, becoming an increasing challenge and expensive hurdle for companies across many industries. This situation is aggravated by the difficulties involved in searching and analyzing patent data, for example, the lack of an online patent database in India. As a result, multinational corporations are largely unaware of the ground realities and are unprepared to operate in such a scenario.
This interactive and practical session will provides useful insights to overcome these challenges and limitations. In this we will cover, various databases that can be used for searching patents in India, their strengths and limitations, and the strategies that one should adopt. We will present a case study that showcases all these aspects.
LUNCH - Noon - 1:30pm
Round Table Discussion Topics
There will be ten concurrent round table discussions. Each session will last 45 minutes and each attendee will be able to participate in three discussion sessions.
Session one: 1:30pm - 2:15pm
Session two: 2:15pm - 3:00pm
Session three: 3:30pm - 4:15pm
The purpose is to provide time for our members to have a free and open discussion on issues of importance to them. No formal presentations will be permitted and no sign up in advance is necessary. There will be a facilitator at each table to ensure that no one monopolizes the conversations nor strays too far from the topic. Vendors are strongly encouraged to participate but are not to regard this as a "sales" opportunity. Our expectation is that this unconstrained exchange of ideas will provide a learning experience for everyone, vendors and customers. We are particularly interested in feedback from attendees as to whether they wish this to be a regular part of our meetings.
- Outsourcing - pros, cons, costs, satisfaction, alternatives.
- Competitive Intelligence - Databases, strategies. NOT patent focused
- Visualization Tools - what do you use, do you like them, why? Alternatives.
- LSA - what's available, pros, cons, deficiencies.
- Citation Analysis - What is the best method for conducting, and interpreting? Which are more important Attorney cites, Examiner cites, or In-Text cites?
- Patent Abandonments - Do you monitor competitive patent abandonments? If so, what in signs do you gain?
- Efficiencies - What are best practices for improving the process efficiencies of searching, analyzing, and disseminating patent information?
- Professional Development
- Chemical Indexing Policies
- Preparing and presenting search report results - different client requirements, report templates, combining results from different databases, and duplicate removal across database hosts
4:15PM - 6:00PM Vendor Exhibits Open - Networking Opportunities
6:30pm - Networking dinner nearby arranged by interested participants PIUG 2009 Northeast Conference Papers - October 2009